# Task: Discuss readable capability labels for Makelore

## Identity

- Task ID: 20261013-capability-copy-febf9c28
- Mode: Feature
- Branch: codex/20261013-capability-copy-febf9c28-capability-copy
- Worktree: C:\Users\7brot\.codex\worktrees\makelore-20261013-capability-copy-febf9c28
- Base commit: 23aa927441d90d7b71a482c91168a2ad26f53d6d
- Owner: codex
- Status: Ready for Integration

## Scope

- Implement the user-approved code-maintained plain-language names/descriptions for platform tools and builtin skills in Makelore catalogs and live/history tool cards.
- Both repositories use isolated worktrees for this task. The previously completed agent deletion task remains separate and untouched.

## Intent And Constraints

- 2026-10-13: User requested merging this completed capability-copy change into both local main branches. Resume for pre-commit checks and fresh read-only review; integration ownership handoff preserves all unrelated records. Push/deployment remain outside scope.

- Make names and descriptions understandable without changing Yuxi runtime identity, model instructions, tool schema, permissions, selections or custom author content.
- User approved the recommended approach with “可以”, then explicitly requested commit/merge to both local main branches. No new admin editor, database fields, automatic translation, push or deployment.
- Concurrent/Planning Gates passed on same-task resume; existing peer scopes were rechecked and no semantic conflict requires a handoff. User explicitly approved one fresh read-only Reviewer for the paired change.

## Outcome

- Yuxi owns one small copy module for platform tools and five builtin skills. Catalog keeps key/name/description; skill source_type prevents rewriting uploaded/imported and personal override text.
- Tool display_name/display_description come from the same module. Frozen per-run configuration identifies local tools and knowledge-derived tools, preserving same-named MCP text and the original execution name. Unknown or source-less history uses the original name. With configured MCP servers, implicit filesystem/Todo/subagent names also keep their raw names because existing snapshots cannot prove whether MCP replaced them; execution rules remain unchanged.
- History batches frozen inputs for its own message runs. Makelore SSE uses the existing authorized stream with an optional output projector after native compaction; raw events and Last-Event-ID remain intact.
- Client Main whitelist, typed tool calls, live reducer and shared personal/channel message component carry and display the new fields. Expanded tool cards retain raw identifiers, arguments, results and errors.
- Skill labels, search and preload wording are Chinese; configuration still stores original keys. README and Yuxi owning documentation describe the behavior. Proposed decision moved to implemented after direct verification.
- Reviewed changes since the recorded bases and inspected the actual Electron reopened tool card. No unrelated source or canonical project memory changed.

## Verification

- Backend: WSL Python 3.12, pytest test/unit/services/test_makelore_capability_copy.py test/unit/services/test_agent_run_service.py -q: 65 passed. Covers same-named MCP, missing source, derived knowledge tools, event batches/single chunks/lifecycle and immutable inputs. New read_file/write_todos/task cases prove raw-name fallback for MCP runs in history and live projection, positive labels without MCP, and retained explicit/knowledge/schedule labels.
- Backend: isolated PostgreSQL on port 58419 and real HTTP, pytest test/integration/services/test_makelore_agents.py -k 'capability_copy or personal_history' -q: 3 passed. Catalog checks builtin/upload/personal overrides, original saved keys and persisted descriptions; SSE checks authorization, replay cursors and unchanged native output; history checks durable labels and visibility.
- Client: pnpm 10.33.4 run typecheck passed. Related cloud-chat-rendering, cloud-agents-main, cloud-agents-page, cloud-agents-management, cloud-agents-workflows and cloud-channel-conversations unit tests: 108 passed in total. The initial old “上传 Skill” selector failed as expected after the rename; updated selector and that file's 3 tests passed.
- Client: build:vite passed; changed-source ESLint passed; real Electron cloud-agents.spec.ts and cloud-chat-rendering.spec.ts: 2 passed, covering readable catalog, live tool card and reopening.
- Documentation: engineering contracts passed; verifier unittest 62 passed in WSL. Windows verifier tests hit existing Unix symlink/path assumptions, so the test suite was run in Linux. VitePress docs build passed with link checking.
- Backend changed-source Ruff passed. Working/cached diff whitespace checks and task-aware documentation drift checks are final gate commands.
- Evidence: C:/Users/7brot/.codex/visualizations/2026/10/12/01a12e4f-9365-74c2-9e57-3f900a028618/capability-copy-local; unit/integration runtime logs also under /tmp/makelore-capability-copy-febf9c28 in WSL.
- Final pre-commit backend non-slow unit suite after the review fix: 2276 passed, 1 skipped (WSL Python 3.12; 59.14 seconds). Engineering contracts passed with 120 decisions; engineering verifier unittest: 62 passed.
- Fresh independent read-only Reviewer found a real implicit-tool/MCP collision that could mislabel the actual MCP implementation. The final projection-only fix preserves raw names when source is uncertain, covering old history without changing runtime behavior. Reviewer independently reran 65 backend tests and 62 client tests, and confirmed the final patch has no open blocking findings (PASS).
- Limits: Redis event retrieval and cloud providers use deterministic fixtures; no paid model calls, production deployment, package installation or child comprehension study.

## Follow-ups

- Independent review and verification are complete; this source result is ready for the authorized commit and integration. Exclusive Integration tasks own both main directories and preserve all five unrelated untracked project records. Integration outcome belongs to their records.
- Task-owned PostgreSQL process stopped after verification; its data and external artifacts are retained.
- Future platform capabilities need presentation entries; custom capability copy remains author-owned.

## Promotion Candidates

- Target: current-state.md / integrated architecture or domain note for Makelore resources.
- Proposal: Yuxi owns Makelore presentation copy; catalog keys/model instructions remain unchanged, and live/history tool display is derived from each run's frozen source.
- Evidence: catalog/save HTTP, SSE/native comparison, history PostgreSQL reread, Main projection and Electron DOM tests.
- Future impact: maintain one server-side copy source and preserve custom provenance when adding capabilities.
- Semantic conflicts: none identified; deletion/purpose tasks stay independent.
- Human confirmation: implementation already approved; canonical promotion requires the normal integration task.